Sunday, October 14, 2012

TOW #5 "The Hit Man's Tale"


                Work is scarce Detroit, Michigan and as a result, drug trafficking has become increasingly prevalent in recent years.  An article titled “The Hit Man’s Tale”, written by Nadya Labi and published in The New Yorker, details how one man named Vincent Smothers turned to the drug business to become a contracted killer.  Labi, formerly a senior editor at Legal Affairs, now writes for The Atlantic.  The New Yorker is a weekly publication well known for its cultural commentaries and was first published in 1925.  The article describes Smother’s plight and provides information regarding the state of poverty within Detroit.  Beyond just analyzing police reports, Labi utilizes conversations she’s had with Smother and others to ask a central question: is there such a thing as an ethical hit man?  For example, when she asked him what he felt about killing his first victim Labi writes that he said, “Emotionally, it didn’t affect me.  It wasn’t, like, ‘Wow, I just killed someone.’”   In addition to using dialogue to establish her credibility as an author, Labi also presents Smothers’ history as a well-performing student from a relatively stable family side-by-side with his unusual career choice as a method of juxtaposition.  For example, she writes, “Charlene Handelman, his twelfth-grade English teacher, said, ‘He wasn’t the first of my honor students who turned to murder-for-hire.’”  By writing in such a straightforward manner, Labi is able to ask that central question of her readers, who are most likely affluent people who have never been at all involved with the drug business, and provide enough information to give them a sense of the difficulties facing the poor of Detroit.   

No comments:

Post a Comment