Monday, May 27, 2013

TOW Grizzly Man

            In October of 2003, Timothy Treadwell, an American environmentalist and grizzly bear enthusiast, was killed and partially eaten by a grizzly bear in a national park in Alaska.  For the previous 13 years, Treadwell had spent his summers isolated in the wilderness of Alaska compiling over 100 hours of footage of these bears.  In 2005, director Werner Herzog included some of this footage in a documentary titled Grizzly Man, which detailed Treadwell’s personal struggle to protect the bears.  Treadwell’s work was a subject of great controversy, as many believed he did more harm than good when living among the grizzly bear population.
            In many ways, Treadwell’s own footage speaks for itself and requires little editing on the part of Herzog.  In fact, Herzog commends his skill as a filmmaker throughout the documentary and points out various directorial decisions that Treadwell makes in order to promote himself as a protector of the environment.  To highlight Treadwell’s mania, Herzog juxtaposes scenes in which Treadwell is almost crying simply because he loves the grizzly bear he nicknamed “Mr. Chocolate” with scenes in which he is shouting obscenities directed at the U.S. Park Service.  In addition, he includes humorous excerpts from Treadwell’s recordings in which he relates his struggles of finding a girlfriend to the grizzly bears’ struggle of finding a mate.  All through just the showing of his own footage, it becomes clear by the end of the movie that even though Treadwell is dedicated to his cause, he is probably mentally unstable.

            To emphasize not only the internal conflict that Treadwell obviously faced, but also the external conflict created by Treadwell’s work and his death, Herzog contrasts shots of Treadwell claiming that he is the only person truly committed to protecting the bears with shots of ecologists and bear experts who describe how Treadwell’s interaction with the bears might have hurt the bear population.  In addition, Herzog interjects at points during Treadwell’s footage and offers his own perspective.  He states that even after watching all of Treadwell’s footage, he never once noticed the bond Treadwell believed he shared with his Grizzly Bear friends.  Ultimately, Treadwell’s life and death reveals the fact that many of us believe there to be an unspoken barrier between humans and wildlife that makes meaningful interaction impossible.

No comments:

Post a Comment